I am very excited to have been selected as an APS Career Mentoring Fellow in 2020. This is a wonderful opportunity to meet with students across the country to speak about career opportunities. As I work as a fellow and in my role as a chair, I have some loose thoughts I would like to share. There is no real “data” here other than my personal experience. And importantly these are my thoughts and in no way represent APS or Adelphi University.

The Big Leagues! As an outsider, I have always wondered why many Olympic athletes fight so hard for The Olympics. Surely there are some sports (basketball, tennis, etc) that come with a large payday if someone makes it to The Olympics. For many sports, there isn’t that much money involved in the game. Very few people are going to get rich playing curling. (Do you “play” curling?) The odds are great that you will make it to The Olympics. And to metal? Whoa! Almost impossible.

Everyone who gets into this knows the odds. They do it because they love it. If you are track star, the idea of running track every day is amazing. These athletes are in it with everything they got, win or lose.

Similarly, baseball players will often spend whole careers in the professional “minor” leagues in hopes of being called up to play in the big leagues making a salary next to nothing. The odds of being a $20M a year starting picture are basically zero. Yet there are countless people are trying to make it. How do you convince them otherwise? Its a hard sell.

When I think of Phds on there way to a tenured faculty position, I often think in this mindset. Its not about the money, or logic, its about trying to make it to the big leagues. These Phds want to make it. When we show these young Phds statistics about the number of people who actually make it – it seems as if no one is listening. We tell them that the odds of getting a faculty position and getting tenure are very low. People keep trying it for it.

I think it is important to tell people the odds. But I think we should also focus on the benefits of leaving academic. Why is getting a job outside Academia good? Why does it rival being a professor? This is where the convincing needs to be placed.

The Benefits of Getting Out of Academia

There are so many wonderful reasons to leave academia for something else, ‘likely better’. Here are just a few:

  • Consistently – In graduate school and during postdocs, your success depends solely on your PI. This can go either way. Your adviser could be awesome! But one of the things I have heard a lot from people that leave academia is stories about how a PI has single-handily had a negative impact on academic careers. (Luckily I personally did not run across this.) When you are working at a company, there is often a consistent review process. People are usually rewarded for being good and hard-working. Of course no system is perfect, but it is refreshing to know that you evaluation comes from multiple sources.
  • Important work – When I left Academia (before I came back) I worked in logistics. I was living the dream of most 5 year old boys. I was on the front line surrounded by trains, giant container-ships, and containers stacked like Legos. I was using my problem solving skills to help companies with processes and company wide software systems. Considering the amount of pollution involved in shipping goods around the world, a small improvement in efficiency of transporting goods could have a more meaningful impact to the world than some abstract academic research topic.
  • Amex Card – I miss my Amex card. Time was important while I worked outside academia. If I had to buy something, I used my corporate amex card and got it done. Then later on – only if it was important – did we figure out if there was an issue, BECAUSE THERE IS ALMOST NEVER A PROBLEM! Universities get so worked up about spending. I can’t tell you how many small orders I have bought (less than $100) where I didn’t ever fill out reimbursement paperwork – because it was going to be so annoying. And how many days, I spent waiting for parts because I had to get a form approved by six different offices to buy a $200 piece of equipment. Harvard had the most streamlined ordering process but even then orders had to be approved before purchase. I miss that my company had the trust in me to just buy something in reason. (Of course, there needs to be a full audit after the fact.)

What Universities, Students, and Companies Should Start Doing

Students and Companies should start getting to know one another sooner. In the past few years, our department has developed an industry board. Read about it here. One of the HUGE takeaways of these experiences is that companies want to get to know our students, because they need to hire folks. I just thought we were being annoying when we reached out to them. We are not. They want to meet students (at all levels) that have interest in working for their Company.

We have to find a way to convince people to give up their “dream of playing in the big leagues” for something else ‘again, likely better’.

(I say this proudly. I had actually given up on becoming a professor weeks before I was hired as one. HAHAHAHA! I am still mad I didn’t get that one job. I got to the third interview and thought I was in.)

Cool social events are conferences are a start. Free food and beer will always motivate graduate students and post docs out for a conversation. But I think we need to do more.

Here are some simple things that could be done:

  • Increased panel discussions at conferences
  • Industry-themed seminar talks at universities with small student lunches.
  • Visits to companies
  • Encourage graduate students and postdocs to participate in activities outside the lab (e.g., tech-transfer) that will help broaden their knowledge base.

From my memory the hardest part was convincing my PI that any activity outside my lab was good. Of course I had good PIs so they always supported whatever crazy thing I did. During my last postdoc, I volunteered with a group of local graduate students and postdocs interested in start-ups. It was fun and I learned a lot from it. Though, I would imagine that my PI wouldn’t have cared at all that I was using one night a week to hang out with this group, I was scared to talk about it. It just wasn’t something you did. That has to change.

The APS Bridge Program does a nice thing. It gives everyone a professional adviser – separate from their research adviser. Universities will often have postdoc and graduate student offices that help students and postdocs make connections. But I think its just to broad and not targeted enough.

Posted in

3 responses to “The Big Leagues! Showing PhDs There are Options Other than being a Professor”

  1. Professor Wright Avatar

    From someone else: I do feel like efforts are being done to address that leaving academia is an option, a good option, and in cases a necessity. I remember from the first conference I went to they showed the stats and had a whole panel of industry people, who love what they do, talk. Perhaps this was cemented in my brain because I don’t like risk and this path isn’t certain. At my REU they did similar talks addressing leaving academia and emphasized this shouldn’t be viewed as the second option or that you failed to make it in academia. There was even an REU student asking if during grad school he could use summers to do industry internships because he likes the business side of things. And the professors discussed this with him, didn’t discourage it but said (similarly to your experience) it would be largely based on who the PI was. Of course, at AAPT this was a topic of conversation too, which is unsurprising.

  2. […] There were two things I loved about the presentation that APS made for the fellows. The first was the slide animation that showed how while > 50% of PhD holders start working at universities only about 30% are still working there after 15 years. The other 20% had slunk to industry jobs. Why not just start there. I wrote about this here. […]

  3. […] goal of becoming a small college professor? This is not a wise decision. I write about this a lot (The Big Leagues! Showing PhDs There are Options Other than being a Professor) and have given talks about it […]

Leave a Reply


Cosmic Pathways, Lab for Kids, and many of the other research activities discussed on this website is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC) under grant no. 2325980. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.