I was watching tiktok yesterday and got hit with this video:

https://vm.tiktok.com/ZMed94rPv/

Clearly this person is ranting about something in K-12 education. But of course it got me thinking. We have been dealing with COVID and online-only learning for about a year now and we haven’t really answered this question. Do we keep to our standards (making class hard but a challenging learning experience) or do we work with our students to keep them on the team keeping retention high? What is A or a C- anymore? People just seem to be locked into the camps they were in last March when the shit hit the fan. Have we made progress on this? Or are we now locked into it deeper than ever? I don’t know, that’s what I am asking it. Please add your comments to this page and keep the discussion going…

Here are some of my thoughts:

Standards: How much should we push our students? Should we push them as much as we did before? While a number of students have new found COVID-related child care, sick, etc, a large majority of my physics majors (who tend to be traditional students) are sitting at home doing the usual, if anything they are picking up more hours at their jobs. Students requesting to join my research team is higher than usual. Which is good because there is plenty to do. But, why shouldn’t we challenge these traditional students really hard? Give them difficult projects and push them? I am not saying this because I want to be evil, although I am as a professor, but rather because I know that thinking critically is not something that comes naturally. You have to force yourself to do it. For me I had to break my initial laziness before I would be willing to think about anything deeply. The way to get there is to push folks. Once you really learn how to think critically, things in life just become easier and opportunities open up.

If your program does not produce tried, trained, and tested graduates what’s the point?

Be Flexible: Students don’t even have to be working a full time job, child care responsibilities, or hit badly with COVID to be run down by the last year. Just being in quarantine is bad enough. My list of things I can do on a given weekend went from near infinity (I live near NYC) to maybe three or four things. This experience is making me go crazy. It is also working on our students. How can you push them at a time like this? Everyone is near their breaking point. It is unsurprising that the fabric of our country is being ripped apart. And oh yes, you have have a two hour physics test that has been specially-crafted, extra-hard, un-cheatable due tomorrow at 8am. When you are on the verge of tears, how do you stay in your program? We don’t even have to dive into how coming from a historically-minoritized group might make matters worse.

If your program does not graduate students, what’s the point?

Even the Discussion is Too Hot: This topic is so sensitive. People on either side of this argument will attack you if you even discuss it or ask questions about. I have been surprised by how fiercely opinioned folks have been. I have been attacked by both sides of the argument.

Is Competition a Good Thing? I am not allowed to play Monopoly at home. I once played my wife and her BFF and within 30 minutes I had hotels up and taking everyone’s money with an evil laugh. We have discovered that Boggle is the best game, because my wife has won 99% of the times we played without trying and I can be as competitive as I want; I just can’t beat her. My competitive mind frame is in fact one of the reasons that Colleen doesn’t want to play board games with me. But it is also exactly this competitive mindset that sees a peer killing it in her field, publishing papers left and right that pushes me hard to keep up with her. Or when I see that I didn’t get the top grade in the class, it pushes me to be the best. (BTW, not good for maintaining friendships, I am sorry.) Honestly we all want Tom Brady on our team. The best competitors are often the best at doing things. We should encourage that right, at least at some level? Or does this force good students that don’t want to compete out?

Perfection is Boring: “I attended every day of school from kindergarten through high school.” Boring! When did you ditch school to go to have stick-sword fight in the woods? When do you have to go to your Uncle’s funeral? School is a good place to learn, but life is much richer than school! You don’t have to be perfect in school to be amazing later in life. There are plenty of folks that have struggled through those years and have had success. [eg me. I failed 1st grade. In Sixth Grade I got all Cs and my dad too me out to eat to celebrate – that’s how bad my grades were. I even had a few Ds in high school.] Why do we have a system that demands perfection and grade inflates so that only the perfect people win? I have often found that people look are perfect look for ways to stay perfect (e.g., take the easy professor). We have to really take a look at grades.

Point of View? There are so many different ways to spin this: field, race, gender, religion, social-economical class, etc. etc. When the University adopts mass pass/fail options for the students it in fact, in my mind, deepens the problem and the confusion. Student 1 has a 4.0 who got (A, A, B-, C turned to A,A,P,P) and student 2 who got a 3.3 got (B+ B+ B+ B+). If the C was in their chemistry class and they were a chemistry major, that doesn’t sounds like a 4.0. ??????

My Canadian Peeps Know the Solution, But I am not Ready For it Yet: There are two awesome Canadian physicists I talk with from time to time. They keep telling me “Mastery Tasks” is the way to go. Similar to Standards-based grading students have to demonstrate they can do each task individually before they can move on. It is something I toyed with in my Matlab Class with limited success.

And So the Question: What does a professor who wants ALL her students to be SUCCESSFUL do?

Posted in

3 responses to “We need to draw a line in the sand somewhere? When is easy too easy and when is hard too hard?”

  1. Fraser Avatar
    Fraser

    At what point did people start expecting that getting an A was a right? And not something earned? Probably when so much money became attached with scholarships and the like.

    Medicine is moving away from assessing med school applicants based on grades, in a way that values experience and complex skills with poorly defined metrics. Not saying interviews, committees, and CVs necessarily do better, but if money is attached to a single number (GPA or whatever), it’s not surprising that there’s pressure behind boosting it.

    Thanks for the food for thought!

    1. Professor Wright Avatar

      I didn’t think about the money aspect

Leave a Reply


Cosmic Pathways, Lab for Kids, and many of the other research activities discussed on this website is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC) under grant no. 2325980. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.