I LOVE SPORTS! I mean I really love sports. I am so happy the Olympics are on. As soon as this post is out, I am sure I am going to hit the sofa and turn the TV on for some track and field, beach volleyball, or 7 on 7 rugby. (The rugby is my favorite from this year.) Or maybe I will turn on a baseball game. I tell you the goal that USA scored in overtime against Mexico in the gold cup literally had me completely in the air cheering yesterday. I love sports and I love competition.
So I was driving a long this morning on the way to beach for a morning run when I heard David Bouchier’s essay on Infinite Games. At first, I was appalled. I might have yelled “Hey Boo-shay, don’t be talking trash about the Olympics!” But then when I took a moment and thought about it, I think he might be on to something.
Childhood and sports is such an intense thing. Just listen to the parents at any sporting event. I am happy to hear that there aren’t too many super young gymnasts in this years Olympics. Even still to become an Olympic athlete at age 20 you have to be crazy determined through a large part of your childhood. I was listing to this interview on the radio of long island diver, Andrew Capobianco (silver metal), who moved across the country and started in a special diving school at age 12! What?! Age 12! My daughter has serious talent when it comes to art, I am not sure I am ready to pick up and move across the country. Does that make me a bad parent? Whatever happened to letting kids be? Tell them to explore and go have fun! Why do we have to get them on travel teams or specialized olympic training?
To David Bouchier’s point, growing up is an infinite game not a finite one. It is not something that should end with a gold metal, or more likely dealing with crushing defeat when one realizes they aren’t good enough. It should be able exploring. It should be about learning. Should we really be surprised when students come to college and struggle with unstructured learning?
Science, too, is an infinite game. We should be careful how much stock we place in robot competitions, science fair competitions, IBM high school research awards, or especially poster competitions at research conferences. Science is about the pursuit of truth, teamwork, and it has a time scale that exceeds any poster competitions. We have to ensure that conferences is not about winning. And it is about the clear dissemination of scientific findings. Pursuing truth is not about winning. And when it becomes about winning, we loose the ability to be careful and objective…because we want to win.
In small doses a little competition is fun. Its good to get professors and other community leaders reading younger student work and providing feedback. It feels good when you win and it is something to be proud of. In small doses…
Counter thought! (Written by a Guest Author)
I actually think competition is one of the best things you can do for a young scientist. In my experience, the most important trait of successful scientists isn’t intelligence or curiosity, but being comfortable failing and not giving up after a lot of work does not pan out. And there’s no better way to learn how to fail gracefully than serious competition. Because you’re not going to win all the time, much like your experiments won’t work all the time. An outsized fraction of the truly outstanding scientists I know played serious competitive sports when they were younger. I don’t think that’s accidental.




Leave a Reply