There are many things that keep me up at night.  Making a mistake and publishing it while doing science is near the top of that list.  I work hard to write in a way that asks questions unless I am sure I know what I am talking about.  Even then, I am always left with a nervous sick feeling when I say something with a period, e.g., “xx happens because of yy.”  Part of that is because I know how precise folks in my field are when it comes to science.  The number of significant known confirmed digits in the Rydberg constant is something like 13. 

When I started making educational physics videos, it took me years to get over making them publicly available because I nervous someone would find fault in the physics I was teaching.  There are a lot of reasons for this such as (1) my OCD (2) untenured and (3) personal confidence.  But I tell you one thing that always bothered me was that I was missing an important detail in my teaching and I would be found out.  (Crap that sounds like imposter syndrome.)

Its not the physicists are assholes.  I know a lot of physicists and I know only couple of people I really don’t like.  However, most physicists are just wonderful people.  But they have trained their minds to ask difficult questions and be relentless in search of the truth.  So if you are not spewing truth then they are going to call you out. 

—

I try to tackle all sides of arguments.  Even when I don’t agree with a person, I try to appreciate and understand their point of view.  I think it is really good to hear the counter points of a particular view and working through them.  This is what lead me to read a number of books this summer that expressed views that would more likely be discussed on FOX news than MSNBC.  (BTW I am a big fan of Rachel Maddow.)  One of the books was “Unsettled” by Koonin. 

Koonin, a physicist, climate scientist, government official, etc, made the claim that there is less known about climate science that we believe.  He suggested the models that claim certain pending doom have significant uncertainty and may in fact be incorrect.  He further suggests that scientists, politicians, journalists are at fault for deliberately cooking the books for their own gain.  There are a lot of people that have strongly come out against this book – check out these two. A New Book Manages to Get Climate Science Badly Wrong and A critical review of Steven Koonin’s ‘Unsettled’

To be honest, this book made me uncomfortable.  Koonin, who has a PhD in physics, sounded like a physicist.  He was asking deep probing questions.  He was curious.  And his thought process similar to how I approach things.  As someone who writes on sensitive topics myself I found the whole book and reading reviews distressing. I definitely felt his point that we need to be conservative with what we say.

I think the science is clear: climate change is happening due to human causes.  The future of the planet is in jeopardy.    However, I find that I know less about this than I should.  I am supposed to be a science expert right?  I do read newspapers, science magazines, books, etc. This book made me want to know more about the global warming.  In particular I am interested in the computer models.  Luckily I am in a position (as a tenured science professor) to learn more about it.  But if I am struggling to digest all this science, what about the regular joe?

Here was my take away from the book:

  • We need to do a much better job of teaching the general public about how to think about science. Think about people giving Dr. Fauci a hard time for not knowing every detail about everything COVID.
  • As scientists, we need to do a better job of communicating our work to everyone. We need to write less for experts and more for the general public. (At least for other scientists.)
  • There is a classic cartoon about academic research. All of the research that someone is an expert in is only a small pimple of all the knowledge we know. I think we need to get back to the enlightenment ideals not be so specialized. We should be able to have a more generalized in how we share knowledge.
  • We really need to train students to be curious.

Posted in

Leave a Reply


Cosmic Pathways, Lab for Kids, and many of the other research activities discussed on this website is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC) under grant no. 2325980. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.