As a physicist, I spend a lot of time discussing orthogonally and completeness of functions/vectors.  In math methods, I spend a lot of time discussing these when I teach Fourier Series.  Again, it comes back up in most of my upper level courses.  I talk about it non-stop in quantum mechanics.

To those of you who do not speak math; orthogonally and completeness are two properties that a class of functions/vectors might have.  It is super useful. In fact so much of quantum mechanics is built off of this one math idea. They basically mean what the management consultant would call MECE, mutuality exclusive and collectively exhaustive.  If you make a list of items, each item should be independent and the list should include every option.  For example, a mutuality exclusive and collectively exhaustive list of fruit would be apples, pears, etc.  The problem being that you have to list every single type of fruit (there is a lot of them).  When writing and applying MECE, it is usually possible to break the list down into three or four points with a little creativity. MECE is a great tool for organizing one’s writing and presentations.

So here is my question for the physics community, do you link MECE and orthogonally-completeness when you teach physics/math students to write?  Should we? 

As I prep my sophomore physics class’s lab, I am going to lay the foundation for this.  Unfortunately, most have not run across Fourier yet.  (In our curriculum, they get it at the end of the semester.)  But I think it is something to talk about and come back to as we learn about the mathematics and how to write for science.

Posted in

Leave a Reply


Cosmic Pathways, Lab for Kids, and many of the other research activities discussed on this website is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC) under grant no. 2325980. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.