Nearly Everyone Gets A’s at Yale. Does That Cheapen the Grade? This was an article in the NY Times today. This is a super interesting article. It is appartent that the author (Amelia Nierenberg) has a similar tiktok feed to me because I was also considering an article on Stuart Rojstaczer’s recent tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZT85E6e81/

As a professor, the difference between each of the grades is important and something I think a lot about. But I don’t lose any sleep thinking about how much “cheaper” an A in 2023 is compared to 1999 or 1969. And that is always what gets the headlines, but I think there are much more insidious things to worry about with grade inflation.

Unlike montary inflation, which allows the dollar to ever increase, the GPA is capped at a score of 4.0. So when grade inflation occurs and most people acheive an A, what does it say about the rest of the students?

Managing GPAs: Students, especially pre-meds, spend a lot of time trying to manage their GPA. This is the reality of being a student (and always has). However, when 80% of the students get As it discourages students to go the extra mile in the class. A student can comfortably do average in the class, managing their assignments, without really diving in a challenging themselves and still get an A. But it also discourages students to take classes and subjects that could led them to anything other than an A. This risk-averse mentality hurts society.

Consider biology vs. chemistry. They share a ton of classes and are similar majors. However, chemistry is preceived as much harder. Both are equally important. Last year (according to collegefactual.com) there were 21k chemistry graduates with a negative rate of growth (-3.4%). Whereas, not only does biology have more students (107k), it also has positive growth rates, +4.8%. (Physics is even worse (13K and -3.3%).) We need more chemists and badly. See this 2022 Physics Today article, that said that we need more chemistry and physics high school teachers. To be crystal clear, I have nothing against biology. In fact it is one of my favorite fields. And I personally know many biology professors that really push their students. But most of the people that study biology go into health. Choosing chemistry, physics, engineering, etc might actually be the better choice for their careers. But the students have to be willing to take the risk.

The thing is, we learn when we take risks. We learn when we push ourselves past our current boundries. While I would argue as a professor that taking the risk and over coming it will give you the best ROI on the college experience, it is nearly impossible to convince the students I advise of that fact, who are narrowly focused on their GPA.

Limited Second Chances: Ask yourself which person you would rather hire:

Person I : First year, C average; Second year, B- average, Junior year B+, Senior year A- :: 3.0 GPA

Person II : First year, A average; Second year, A average, Junior year B+, Senior year B :: 3.5 GPA

It is not obvious of course. We would need some interviews of course. Concerning their GPA, we might ask Person I why they did poorly in their first year. They might respond about how they were an 18-punk who though they knew everything before learning they had to start working hard. That would be reasonable – don’t ask me how I know. Seeing their continual growth over time shows that they are (1) able to learn, (2) improve against their peers, and (3) have grit. Does person II have that?

With more and more students who get As its hard to expose Person II. But even worse, the semester where that student gets a C average sticks out like a sore thumb. It has drastic long-term effects on the GPA. One semester of bad grades have a hug effect that last through out the college career!

What about competency based grading?

Posted in

Leave a Reply


Cosmic Pathways, Lab for Kids, and many of the other research activities discussed on this website is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC) under grant no. 2325980. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.