This morning I was listening to the College Matters podcast on my way to work.  They had rebroadcasted a FutureU podcast, “Making Sense of the First 100 Days”.  It was an excellent discussion on the future of Higher Ed.  I highly recommend it.

International students have been a hot topic of discussion lately.  While listening to this discussion this morning I had an idea.  It would be interesting to know if it was true.

Here’s the problem:

There has been a recent downward trend in the number of physics students in college.  This has been particularly true at 4-year colleges. 

The general feeling among the people I have talked to is illustratrated by my sketch.  Making it into college physics program is tough.  A student has to wade through a number of math and science courses at the high school level before they even get to college.  Then Covid comes by and it’s like throwing a giant boulder on someone who is mountain climbing – its hard to climb that mountain yo!  Thus in the end there are fewer students who are ready and interested in pursuing something in physics, mathematics or electrical engineering. 

Here’s the idea:

Now, in addition to Covid issues, international students may be playing a huge role in physics and mathematics enrollment – but the problem might show up in local and regional colleges and universities.  Here’s why maybe.

Universities are interested in accepting international students.  Why?  Dollar Bills Y’all!  International students typically pay near-full tuition whereas domestic students will usually pay less.  Ok but the number of international students still may be low university-wide (at least in many schools).   

We already know that about 1/2 of the graduate students in physics, math, chemistry, material science, and electrical engineering are international.  There just aren’t enough domestic students to fill those roles.  At the undergraduate level, these disciplines likely have a higher proportion of international students.  This is literally a wild guess and I have no ideas of the numbers across college and universities.  It would be interesting to know.

Due to recent news events, we all know that international students are feeling increasingly unwelcomed.  Many I bet are choosing to go to school else where in the world because of this.

This has created program holes in elite schools.  With all of the budget cuts, they want to make sure they fill them domestic students.  So they are could more accepting of physics students, ultimately taking away students away from the 4-year college???  This is going to put even more strain on 4-years physics, chemistry, and mathematics programs.

Ultimately the fact that most people who choose physics pathways in college are elite high school students will amplify this process.  (We tried to give a scholarship to a current student whose high school GPA was under 4.0 and we couldn’t do it – because our students all did better in high school.)  Most of students who would consider physics pathways will already be near the threshold to getting into elite schools, so it will be reasonable for the elite schools to just let them in.

Am I making things up?  I don’t know.  But it does tell a good story.  I guess we are going to have to wait to see what the data says.   

I will keep promoting physics. Maybe the solution is to build a phd program.

Posted in

2 responses to “Trying to Make Sense of Low Enrollment in the Physical Sciences”

  1. Phil B Avatar
    Phil B

    Is another part of the solution ensuring that the necessary prerequisites that you describe (e.g., algebra, geometry, trig, precalc, calc) are taught as early as possible to students? In many other countries (and therefore, most international students), these levels of mathematics are taught at least 2-3 years before they would be taught in America, outside of some specialized programming.

    1. Professor Wright Avatar

      very interesting!!

Leave a Reply


Cosmic Pathways, Lab for Kids, and many of the other research activities discussed on this website is supported by the National Science Foundation and the Physics Teacher Education Coalition (PhysTEC) under grant no. 2325980. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.